As fishing can be hit or miss this time of year, my fishing buddy David came along and fished my 8.5 Foot F.E. Thomas Dirigo bamboo rod as a "control". We are at about the same skill level, and he fishes this river in much the same style I usually wood. The day was slow, but by the end I had caught one trout (on a Fuji tenkara dry fly), and he had caught six on casts of three wet flies. As far as I am concerned, on fish on a dry is worth 5 sub-surface, so we came out pretty even. On another type of river, I doubt there would be much of a disparity.
More important than the number of fish caught is the experience of fishing with a particular rod, or in a particular style. An on that front Tenkara holds up pretty well.
Ease of hiking/wading
The compact nature of a telescopic rod is truly freeing, especially when bushwhacking through dense brush and blackberry brambles. When I first set out toward the river, I was able to simply stick the rod in my pack , and once it had the fly and line on it, it was easy to wrap the line around my hand or line spool, and walk with the rod collapsed. I didn't have to worry about navigating the tip of a fly rod eight feet in front of me between branches and vines.
Casting
Casting tenkara style is pretty easy. Within about ten minutes I was making accurate casts, and after about an hour I was no longer thinking about casting and was just fishing. While I don't think I got caught in tree branches more often than with other rods, I did get tangled in different branches. In general I had to be more aware of higher branches than usual and less aware of of what was way behind me.
Presentation
The long rod and light, fixed length line allow for amazingly long dead drifts, especially with dry flies. With wet flies and nymphs I found myself more aware of the tip of the fly rod than with western style fly fishing. Instead of controlling the depth of the fly with line slack and weighted flies, I was able to control it by lowering and raising the rod tip.
Playing/Landing a Fish
The particular rod I was using transmitted feeling from the end of the line to my hand as well as my favorite bamboo and fiberglass rods. I was able to feel the trout take my dry fly as soon as it happened and was able to hook up with ease. The only fish I landed was not big, but it was fun to play him on the long rod and line. I was standing next to a large current, but I was able to play him into the slow water with side pressure and quickly bring him to the net.
All-in-all, I really enjoyed fishing tenkara style. I don't think I would bring it back to the lower Stanislaus again, but the I will definitely be bring it with me to smaller rivers, mountain streams, and larger rivers with a lot of pocket water. I can see taking it with me on day hikes that may or may not give fishing opportunities, and maybe investing in a slightly shorter rod for very small trout in tight spaces.
--Posted by Eben
RSS Feed

